Skip to main content

Search

Hi, how can we help?

    Gift vs. Cash Incentives for Influencers

    Olivya
    • Updated

    In this Article:

    There are multiple incentives, or payment methods, to choose from when working with influencers and creators. An incentive is any type of payment or gift provided to influencers for their participation in a campaign. For more details on incentive options, see Incentive Overview.

    Choosing the right incentive format for influencers and creators depends on your campaign goals, budget, and the type of influencers you’re targeting. In general, the most common incentive types are gifts, cash, or a combination of both.

    What is gifting?

    A gift incentive involves providing free products or services to influencers in exchange for content creation or promotion. With gifting, the creation of content can be guaranteed with a binding contract (Later Influence Standard Influencer Agreement), but it’s also very common not to be guaranteed. 

    Gift incentives are often ideal for smaller budgets, building organic relationships, and engaging niche audiences through nano- and micro-influencers. 

    What are cash incentives?

    Cash incentives involve paying influencers a set fee for their collaboration, typically tied to deliverables like posts, stories, or videos. With cash incentives, content is guaranteed as the brand and creator(s) agree upon and fulfil a contract (Later Influence Standard Influencer Agreement). 

    Cash incentives are best for brands with larger budgets seeking guaranteed deliverables and the ability to scale campaigns with macro- or mega-influencers.

    Gifting Benefits & Drawbacks

    The benefits and drawbacks of gift incentives are summarized below:

    Benefits Drawbacks
    • Cost-Effective: Gifting is more budget-friendly, especially for smaller brands or startups
    • Product Sampling: It introduces influencers to your product firsthand, building genuine advocacy if they enjoy it
    • Low Commitment: No contractual obligation means you can test partnerships with less risk
    • Organic Content: Influencers who genuinely love the product may share content that feels more authentic to their audience
    • Uncertainty: If there isn’t an agreement between the brand and influencer, there's no guarantee influencers will post or promote your product
    • Limited Reach: Gifting is typically more effective with nano- and micro-influencers who are more likely to engage without cash
    • Perceived Value: Some influencers may not value gifting if your product doesn’t align with their brand or audience

    Cash Incentive Benefits & Drawbacks

    The benefits and drawbacks of cash incentives are summarized below:

    Benefits Drawbacks
    • Guaranteed Deliverables: Paid collaborations typically include a contract with specific content deliverables and timelines
    • Wider Reach: Larger influencers (macro and mega) are more likely to participate when offered cash
    • Customization: Cash incentives allow you to negotiate specific campaign goals, such as content formats or promotion across multiple platforms
    • Professional Relationships: Paid partnerships encourage influencers to treat the collaboration more seriously and deliver high-quality content
    • Higher Costs: Cash incentives require a larger upfront investment, which may not be feasible for smaller brands
    • Authenticity Concerns: Some audiences may view paid posts as less genuine, particularly if not disclosed properly
    • ROI Risks: There’s no guarantee that the investment will yield conversions or meaningful engagement

    ROI Potential of Each Method

    The ROI (return on investment) potential for each method is summarized below:

    Gifting ROI Cash Incentive ROI
    • Cost Basis: The ROI is often higher because the cost is limited to the product value and shipping
    • Influencer Type: Best with nano- and micro-influencers who have high engagement rates and loyal followers
    • Brand Awareness: Generates authentic buzz, UGC (user-generated content), and initial impressions
    • Challenges: Tracking ROI can be difficult unless you use tools like discount codes or referral links
    • Predictable Returns: Cash partnerships allow for structured campaigns with measurable outcomes
    • Scalability: Works well for macro-influencers to achieve large-scale awareness and conversions
    • Better Attribution: Contracts often include metrics tracking (clicks, sales, etc.), making it easier to assess ROI
    • Challenges: Higher costs mean a poorly-performing campaign can lead to lower overall ROI

    Blended Strategy for Optimal ROI

    Many brands combine both methods by reaching out to a variety of influencers offering gifting or cash, or combining both:

    • Gifting for discovery and cultivating authentic partnerships with smaller influencers
    • Cash for scaling campaigns or working with larger influencers to target broader audiences
    • Gifting + Cash for creators to feature products and/or services in paid social campaigns with a guarantee to reach a wide variety of audiences

    Comparison of Gifting, Cash, and Blended Incentives

    Aspect Gifting Cash Incentives Blended
    Budget Low-to-moderate Moderate-to-high Moderate-to-high
    Influencer Type Nano- and micro-influencers Nano- to mega-influencers Combination of both
    Expected Output Organic, voluntary content Guaranteed content with contracts Combination of organic and paid posts
    Expected ROI Low-to-moderate ROI, strong engagement with niche audiences, hard to measure sales impact High ROI potential, as campaigns with macro-influencers drive significant awareness and measurable conversions, but with higher risk due to cost Balanced ROI, leveraging the cost-efficiency and authenticity of gifting while benefiting from guaranteed reach and conversions with paid influencers
    Measurement
    • Hashtags
    • UGC tracking
    • Discount codes
    • Affiliate links
    • Metrics
    		 ROI comparison across both tiers

    For details on setting up cash and gift incentives, see Incentive Setup and Product Incentives.

    Can’t find your answer?Contact Us
    Return to top
    Privacy Policy Terms of Use