In this Article:
Recruiting creators is not just about sending messages — it’s about strategic, respectful engagement that leads to meaningful partnerships. Below is a more holistic guide combining process, mindset, and practical tips.
Start with Strategy: Define Your Goals & Budget
Before you even search for creators, set clear objectives.
- Are you aiming for awareness, engagement, or sales? Later’s strategy guide emphasizes defining SMART goals to guide campaign direction.
- Decide your budget framework (flat rates, per-post, gifting plus cash) so you know what types of creators you can realistically engage.
Having goals first prevents “throwing money at influencers without direction.”
Build & Refine Your Creator Shortlist
Later’s How to Find the Right Influencers article offers strong tactics:
- Use filters like niche, audience demographics, engagement, and past performance.
- Monitor creators already engaging with your brand (tagging, UGC, mentions) — these tend to be more responsive and authentic.
Write Outreach That Resonates
Many outreach messages fail because they feel generic or ask too much too soon. Later’s guide Influencer Outreach: How to Effectively Reach Out to Creators offers a solid framework.
Do’s:
- Personalize — reference a particular post or style you admire.
- Be concise and value-focused — what’s in it for them?
- Include your onboarding or campaign link in the first message.
- Use messaging templates, but adapt so it doesn’t feel copy-paste.
Don’ts:
- Don’t make the ask before building rapport.
- Avoid long blocks of text or vague statements.
- Don’t undercut creators’ rates or make demands that seem non-negotiable.
Engagement Beyond the Outreach
Once you contact creators, don’t go silent.
- Follow up strategically. Most creators receive numerous messages — a simple reminder is often effective.
- Engage with their content — like, comment, share. This builds visibility and goodwill.
- DMs can personalize communication, but always mirror your email tone and context.
Use Quality, Not Quantity (Especially with Gifting)
From Later’s Influencer Gifting & Seeding Done Right:
- A smaller, curated list often delivers better ROI than mass gifting.
- Add personal touches (notes, tailoring gifts to the creator’s style) to make the outreach feel thoughtful.
If you’re a small business, you might have a limited budget for paid collaborations—that’s okay! If creators love your product or service, they’re often willing to collaborate in exchange for coupons and discounts. Don’t be afraid to offer these incentives as an alternative to monetary compensation.
Brief Creators Smartly
A good brief reduces confusion, revisions, and frustration. Later’s How to Write Influencer Briefs for Great Campaigns provides solid structure.
Include:
- Content expectations (formats, styles, captions)
- Visuals/logos to use or avoid
- Brand messaging or mandatory tag rules
- Timeline and due dates
- No-go zones (e.g. topics, language)
Let creators bring their voice — structure is key, but micromanaging kills authenticity.
Set Realistic Expectations on Response Rates
On average, the industry response rate to cold outreach is around 10%.
That means:
- If you want 10 creators to participate, plan to reach out to at least 100 or more.
- It’s normal (and expected) to only hear back from a small portion of creators you contact.
Bonus Tips
- Use message templates + drafts for efficiency, but always personalize before sending.
- Segment creators by tier (nano, micro, macro) — outreach and incentives often differ.
- Be transparent about bonuses, freebies, or pay terms upfront.
- Always request rights/usage in your contract or messaging — UGC can be repurposed.
- Stay respectful of “no’s” — not every creator will fit your brand or timing.
We’re here to help!
Our Services team is dedicated to helping you source the best creators and run the most effective campaigns for your unique business.
To learn how you can start working with our team of experts and leverage their skills and knowledge, book a call →